I personally think that Alton Harbour is a really good idea for a theme! What I love about this idea is that the pirate theming of Mutiny Bay and SW8's cult worship/Pagan theming could coexist together in harmony much better than Mutiny Bay and the Flume ever did. Even if something like this doesn't happen, I still think that Mutiny Bay will at least see some sort of change in direction with regards to theming, if not a full re-theme. Ladyofthelake over on TowersTimes Forum has said that she thinks that Alton are deemphasising the pirate theme of the area with the courtyard redevelopment and the stage removal, and I think she may be right, because the new restaurant plans do not really lend themselves to a pirate theme.
I was also having a think about what the USP could be. I was only thinking that because John Wardley once said in a Q&A that for an attraction to be granted permission to be built by Nick Varney, it needs a compelling proposition (USP) and a killer image. Then, I suddenly had a thought that the lift hill could be the USP, because as far as I'm aware, no other roller coaster has a lift hill that changes ascent angle midway up like this one. Not that the GP are interested in an angle changing lift hill, but I wouldn't put it past the Alton marketing team after "the world's first roller coaster fully dedicated to virtual reality". It would also be quite funny if this was the USP, because instead of keeping everything secret and letting rumours build, like with past SWs, they would have literally been dangling the USP right in front of us and no one would have noticed. The only reason I'm thinking the lift hill's angle change could even be a USP is because the rumours of a launched lift hill look to have gone the same way as the Smiler washing machine rumour (Yes, I do read through past topics sometimes!) On the other hand, I'm not sure if there's even going to be a USP with this project, as none of the marketing seems to hint towards one.
Finally, I'd just like to say that I think that this could surprise a lot of people in 2018. Do I think that this will better Blackpool's efforts? In terms of coaster, probably not. In terms of theming and immersion, probably. I feel that even if this doesn't beat Icon, it will still be a great family ride that will be loved by many theme park enthusiasts. I'm optimistic that Merlin has listened to criticism and put in time and effort with this development. Not that Merlin's past coasters at Alton haven't had time and effort put into them, but I think this could be on another level compared to past Merlin rides. Also, I'm staggered at how much my thoughts on what the ride would be have changed since the plans were released in 2016. Here's what I thought then and what I thought now:
Then
Theme: Pirate theme
Area: Mutiny Bay
USP: World's first launched inverting woodie
Now
Theme: Tribal/cult worship theme
Area: Re-themed/re-imagined Mutiny Bay
USP: Honestly don't know if there's going to be one
What do you guys think of my theories? I apologise for the long post, but I just had so much I wanted to say.