AT86
TS Member
I would be more than confident it would poll top of the list. Wickerman is extremely popular but enthusiasts also make up a decent percentage of the public and don’t rate it highly.
The park isn’t the same without it, whereas I would quite happily miss out any other of the coasters (perhaps not Oblivion) when I visit.
Whilst I agree that Nemesis is very likely to be rated highly by guests, which would be one of the compelling reasons to retrack it as opposed to remove it, I would disagree that enthusiasts make up a decent percentage of overall numbers.
In comparison to the 2.5million or so people through the gates each year enthusiasts are a tiny fraction. Take the entire membership of this site (4,200) as an example - it equals 0.1% of yearly visitation.