I am one of the CATCF voters you are referring to, and unfortunately, I never got to ride TT or ATWI80D, nor have I experienced ATD. So it is the only incarnation of the ride system I’ve ever ridden.
However, I must say I did rather like CATCF! I have many incredibly fond memories of riding it with my mum when I wasn’t tall enough to ride the big rides, and even when I was, I still enjoyed the occasional ride on it! I remember it having lots of nice theming, and I remember finding the elevator simulator really cool!