Icon or Wicker Man?

[Ash84]

I refuse to decide which is 'better' as I really like both, and both provide the park they are in with a great addition. My first ride on Wickerman didn't impress me but my more recent visits it really impressed me.

Icon has been consistent, in that it's pretty poor first thing and absolutely wild by the end of the night, but that can be said for most coasters.

Ash

 

[bluesonichd]

WM. not been to Pool since last year.
Icon just does nothing for me.

 

[Rob]

Wicker Man for me, just. Like others have said though I had very low expectations for Wicker Man and it was not actually that bad and I had quite high expecatations for Icon which it did not meet.

Niether Wicker Man or Icon come anywhere close to the best of each coaster model that I have ridden (Wodan and Helix). Wicker Man is not the poorest GCI that I have ridden (InvadR says hello) but Icon is the poorest of the Mack Megas that I have ridden.