I love the smiler and have since it opened. Of course we like the ride (the majority anyway...) we like some other rides more though. Yes, it has been criticized, but it deserves to be criticized! It opened late, has been plagued with issues, and has stalled (coasters should never stall). The effects are often broken.
Does this mean I dislike it? NO!! I dislike only one coaster at towers, Rita, and that's because I find it unbearably rough. Some are better than others, but I rate most of towers coasters higher than most other rides in the world - the smiler included!
I love The Smiler. It's a great coaster. The anticipation in the queu line is tremendous, the music whilst you wait is intimidating and I love the drop out of the station before any lift hill because it is so unconventional and gets the adrenaline flowing straight away. I also love the more cheerful version of the formerly intimidating music at the end of the ride to show that you have been corrected.
It is disorienting and forceful to the extent that I never know quite where I am
My favourite part is the second of the two bunny hops where the G Forces clearly max out.
Is it perfect... no. I still think it would work better as a 12 inversion coaster with conventional drops as opposed to inverted drops after each lift hill. Most of the time the roughness doesn't bother me, but if it had the silky smoothness of the B and M's it would be a better ride. Only B and M can achieve this ride quality, but only Gerstlauer can fit such an epic coaster in such a small space. It's also great to have a coaster that isn't over in a minute.
The Smiler is a great coaster and I can't wait to have it back, but as fantastic as it is, just half a mile away is a coaster that gets everything right, is a work of genius and is one of the best, if not THE BEST coaster in the world, the mighty NEMESIS. It beats The Smiler in every department apart from duration .
But hey... coming second to Mohommed Ali, the greatest of all time is no disgrace... that's how I feel about The Smiler. If SW8 can deliver on the intensity of Nemesis, with the duration of The Smiler, then AT will have a trio of coasters that would hold their own in any park in the world.