Matt.GC
TS Member
But this wasn't a smoothness competition.Finally rode Smiler last night, on the front row, and it was a lot smother than saw, so that's where my vote goes now!
-
ℹ️ Heads up...
This is a popular topic that is fast moving Guest - before posting, please ensure that you check out the first post in the topic for a quick reminder of guidelines, and importantly a summary of the known facts and information so far. Thanks.
The Smiler vs Saw The Ride; which Merlin Gerstlauer do you prefer?
- Thread starter Matt N
- Start date
Altonadvocate1
TS Member
Definitely The Smiler for me.
Actually has a decent ride length which is rare in the UK and despite the concrete pit, there is loads to see as you get up close and personal with the coaster which I actually find entertaining.
I have never found The Smiler rough and controversially I have never found an hour listening to the music irritating.
So overall, good ride length, intimidating theme, intimidating music, 1 good and 1 great pop of airtime, record breaking inversions which I do not find repetitive. What's not to like?
Though a distant second to Nemesis in my book, it's still a great thrill coaster and my UK number 2.
I find Saw very pedestrian.
Actually has a decent ride length which is rare in the UK and despite the concrete pit, there is loads to see as you get up close and personal with the coaster which I actually find entertaining.
I have never found The Smiler rough and controversially I have never found an hour listening to the music irritating.
So overall, good ride length, intimidating theme, intimidating music, 1 good and 1 great pop of airtime, record breaking inversions which I do not find repetitive. What's not to like?
Though a distant second to Nemesis in my book, it's still a great thrill coaster and my UK number 2.
I find Saw very pedestrian.
Connor98
TS Member
- Favourite Ride
- Hyperion
Having voted Saw, I had one of the best rides on The Smiler for years on Saturday! Second row end seat and it still ran pretty well. Yes the obvious jolts in the usual places were still there, however it seemed like the vibrations were hardly noticeable and overall it was great fun. But it really does need some TLC. The queue line was in a terrible state, the speakers at the half way point didn’t work at all, and half the effects on the marmaliser and in the station also did not work.
Skyscraper
TS Member
- Favourite Ride
- Nemesis
Yeah Saw's indoor section is great, best bit of the ride for me.
Shaggy_Dog_
TS Member
- Favourite Ride
- Ride To Happiness
There’s maybe an argument to be had that Saw’s indoor section is one of the best dark rides in the UK!
NuttySquirrel
TS Member
- Favourite Ride
- Batman: Gotham City Escape
Smiler has a miserable queueline in which you'll be waiting around an hour, and you'll come off it with a headache. It's worth it though.
When I last rode Saw I skipped the miserable queue in favour of single rider so waited max. 5 minutes, and came off it with a headache. It definitely wasn't worth it.
When I last rode Saw I skipped the miserable queue in favour of single rider so waited max. 5 minutes, and came off it with a headache. It definitely wasn't worth it.