• ℹ️ Heads up...

    This is a popular topic that is fast moving Guest - before posting, please ensure that you check out the first post in the topic for a quick reminder of guidelines, and importantly a summary of the known facts and information so far. Thanks.
  • ⚠️ Online Safety Act Changes

    We've made some changes to the forum as a result of the Online Safety Act. Please check the post in guest services for further information.

Which Merlin park is best operated?

Which Merlin park is best operated?


  • Total voters
    29

Matt N

TS Member
Favourite Ride
Shambhala (PortAventura Park)
Hi guys. Here in the UK, we have four Merlin parks: Alton Towers, Thorpe Park, Chessington World of Adventures and Legoland Windsor. Operations are a contentious topic surrounding the Merlin parks, particularly as of late; people talk a lot about throughputs, ride availability and the like with regard to these properties. However, there’s arguably some variation between the four properties in terms of many of these metrics, so with this in mind, I’d be keen to know; which Merlin park is best operated, in your view? Which one performs best in terms of metrics like throughputs?

Personally, I would put Alton Towers at the top of the pile. But if I were to rank them, I would say the following:
  1. Alton Towers - The park may not be perfect, but in general, I think it’s the one that seems to have the most consistently strong operations. Throughputs are broadly excellent, on the whole, with lots of trains running and quick dispatches, the staff seem generally good at batching people and encouraging guests to fill seats, and ride availability, while extremely inconsistent at best in 2023 and 2024, generally seems to have been a lot better this season. I would say that Alton Towers is broadly very good operationally.
  2. Thorpe Park - I have to say that I think Thorpe Park gets an unfair amount of flack for operations. From my experiences, the park are generally pretty decent at getting good ride throughputs; particularly as of late, there does seem to have been a bit of a throughput push at Thorpe Park. On my visits, rides generally seem to be running at full capacity and dispatching fairly promptly, for the most part. Granted, I don’t think the park is quite as slick as Towers in some regards; for instance, I don’t think they’re quite as proactive as Alton at batching and encouraging guests to fill seats. Nonetheless, I find that Thorpe Park generally do a decent job, and I don’t think ride availability is that bad either. On some rides, I would even argue that Thorpe Park like-for-like does better than Alton Towers; for instance, Stealth consistently seems to get a good peg higher than Rita in terms of throughputs, from my experience.
  3. Legoland Windsor - Here’s where I think things dip slightly. It might be down to a greater lack of intrinsically high capacity rides, but I find the queues at Legoland seem to move more slowly than at Thorpe and Towers. In general, I think the coasters seem to do OK, but could go faster. For instance, Dragon was doing a little over 3 minutes per dispatch on my last visit, which seems a little on the slower side for a simple lap bar coaster running multiple trains. Minifigure Speedway was also impeded by the same weird quirk as Mandrill Mayhem, where they won’t let you wait on the platform. Some of the non-coaster rides also seemed a bit short-staffed; for instance, Flight of the Sky Lion had one person running the whole show batching-wise, and it was resulting in a dispatch interval probably no quicker than 10 minutes or so. To be fair, though, availability seemed good on my visit and I don’t really remember anything breaking down.
  4. Chessington World of Adventures - Granted, I’ve only been once in the last decade, but Chessington definitely seemed like the Merlin park that struggled the most operationally on my 2023 visit. Most rides seemed very short-staffed; for instance, Vampire had one person who had to handle both batching and restraint checking, resulting in some of the slowest operations I’ve ever witnessed in a Merlin park (around 400pph on 2 trains…). This story continued across multiple rides. Croc Drop had one poor man running the entire ride on his own. Tomb Blaster had one poor man who had to batch, check and send the entire train. Dragon’s Fury was also strangely operated, taking a good 50% longer to send each car on average than Spinball Whizzer and only 3/4 filling most of the cars (?). To be fair, Mandrill Mayhem wasn’t doing badly at all for a 1 train shuttle coaster (around 3 minutes per dispatch), but most things seemed short staffed and quite slowly operated as a result. I went on a Sunday in September that was not obscenely busy, and there were many rides where the advertised queue breached 60 minutes (I saw Dragon’s Fury on 100 at one point!).
But I’d be keen to know: which Merlin park do you feel is best operated? Do you agree with my ranking?
 
Thorpe all the way. Dont know if we're just lucky there and unlucky at Towers but we tend to get on more at Thorpe than we ever do at Towers.

When the staff are on the ball they're great, I think Inferno is the only of the Nemesises we've pulled into an empty station when both trains are running - it's only happened once but it's never happened at Towers. Stealth is run better than Rita too in my experience.

Plus there's other non op benefits, like a better selection of food options (I can actually get coffee and cake at Thorpe, I can't at Towers), it's cleaner, and although it gets a lot of stick for it's teen demographic the majority of times I've found it's fine.
 
Thorpe all the way. Dont know if we're just lucky there and unlucky at Towers but we tend to get on more at Thorpe than we ever do at Towers.

When the staff are on the ball they're great, I think Inferno is the only of the Nemesises we've pulled into an empty station when both trains are running - it's only happened once but it's never happened at Towers. Stealth is run better than Rita too in my experience.

Plus there's other non op benefits, like a better selection of food options (I can actually get coffee and cake at Thorpe, I can't at Towers), it's cleaner, and although it gets a lot of stick for it's teen demographic the majority of times I've found it's fine.
Your 100% right. I've noticed the qué lines to be less graffitied than alton. Alton has worse food and the ents at thorpe seem lacking but still better than Alton. I also think Thorpe feels fresher as of late. I know the dome and bridge will always date the park but you can't help but say its always given plenty of bright paint.

I just wish they would work on the park entry at TP.

For me
Coasters TP
Flat Rides TP
Dark Rides AT
Food TP
Presentation (litter etc) TP
Entrance Experience AT
Freshness TP
Staff TP
 
For me, best operated in my opinion would be Thorpe Park however it is awfully patchy depending on the ride.

My only bug bear about Thorpe is that staff don't bother calling out for people if they have empty seats where there is no SRQ.

This however is also quite common at other overseas parks too like Parque Warner.
 
I’ve given this a lot of thought and I can honestly say none of them.

They all have their positives, but they all also have different operational issues.

Up until a few years ago I would have said Alton Towers, but things have definitely gone downhill there too.
 
Top