It’s not difficult to make a case for removing the fire effects. These kinds of large special effects never were that common. In Europe we had Valhalla, the Studio Tram Tour at Disney and Templo Del Fuego at Port Aventura, plus a few big stunt shows, and other attractions with individual effects like the fire effects on Tidal Wave, The Swarm, Scorpion Express and Wicker Man.
Has there ever been a ride with such impressive effects and such small vehicles? Kongfrontation and Jaws both had about 50 people in a car/boat. Even The Mummy has 16 person ride vehicles. The smaller the vehicles, the more intimate the experience, but also the less cost effective it is to run the effects for each vehicle.
However, I haven’t got massively high hopes for a refurb, if it’s even going to get completed given the current situation. Even before the crisis the Pleasure Beach seemed to be strapped for cash. There are all kinds of things a refurb could include, but I doubt we’ll get the complete works.
Even if they are able to save a lot of money by replacing the fire effects, I’m not sure how much it’ll help in the long run. When Frontierland closed a lot of people said it’d secure the future of the Pleasure Beach, because all of Frontierland’s visitors would go there instead. Since we’ve had the closure of Camelot and Pleasureland is now a smaller phoenix park. I’m not sure it’s helped all that much, in terms of boosting the Pleasure Beach’s attendance. At the same time, we’ve had 15 years of cut backs at the Pleasure Beach. Most of the shows have gone, as have a lot of support rides and the opening hours have been cut. After 15 years of cost-cutting it doesn’t feel like they’ve ended up in a bright place with healthy profits. It might well be that without the cost cutting and closures they’d have gone bankrupt, but I’m not quite sure what the plan is now. Mothballing Valhalla would save a lot of money, but also close one of their two biggest rides and last major water ride. It hardly falls into the category of modernising the park. Even bringing it back with cheaper effects will look like an event on the long slide of cost cutting.
Hopefully the Pleasure Beach has some kind of trick up their sleeves, because Valhalla or no Valhalla, fire or no fire, they need some kind of inspiration.