I don't think there's ever been an issue with managers pandering to enthusiasts.
Some parks have more time for enthusiasts than others. Some have official fan clubs, such as Europa Park and Disney’s (admittedly expensive) D23 Club and Blackpool Pleasure used to run the 235 Club. Some parks have featured museums (such as Europa Park and Dollywood) which are clearly aimed at the more intense enthusiast. As an enthusiast I don’t necessarily expect these things, but it’s certainly nice when they’re there. Nonetheless, I do think theme parks should make some time for the enthusiasts. Not out of a moral obligation, but it just makes good business sense.
Having said that, I think Alton Towers has made a reasonable amount of time for the fans. In the early years of Merlin they ran the Customer Council which seemed to be very popular. More recently they did open some of the archives as part of their Christmas Market, and Nick Varney wrote a fairly lengthy letter to Towers Street in response to a petition. There have also been some events clearly designed with the enthusiasts in mind, for example around Corkscrew leaving. More recently they’re doing something for Nemesis’ 21st. John Wardley has always had a lot of time for enthusiasts and Alton Towers have made arrangement for enthusiasts to do special filming, although with the Internet the demand for that kind of thing has shot up making it harder to get their time.
You could argue that John Wardley retiring has left a vacuum, and to some people it might feel like the enthusiasts are less connected with the park than they have been in the past. This is one of the ways that John Wardley’s retirement will be a loss, and hopefully over time the void will be filled. John Wardley’s relationship with the enthusiast community grow over several decades, and it will be a while before anyone else can have the same role, but maybe in time. You could also argue that Alton Towers aren’t famous for embracing the enthusiasts in the same way that some independent parks have done, such as Oakwood when it was family run, or Holiday World and Knoebels. But then again I don’t think the corporate parks ever will have that kind of relationship.
All in all Alton Towers has made a reasonable amount of time for the fans. Yes, they could do more. But they’ve done an acceptable amount. Certainly as much as most of the corporate parks would do. Hopefully these things will continue in the future. But I don’t think that’s the main reason you get a lot of negativity on this forum. People wouldn’t moan if they didn’t care. We want Alton Towers to be the best, just as a football fan wants their team to be the best. I think most of us would agree that Alton Towers still is a great theme park, but to some of us it feels like they’re riding on past successes, and not really pushing themselves to be the best they can be.