Quite agree - in the dark, nothing even comes close to Nemesis
The Smiler for me feels more like an endurance event. Queue, the farting crappy "subs", the queue, the queue, the queue..... the queue. Then ride. I also had a bit of a rougher car for it the only ride I had on it the other day, I have to say, I PREFERRED it to the smooth cars! I actually don't feel as rough at the end bizarrely. Then I don't like air for that reason, too "floaty".
Nemesis though at night. Doesn't feel that way. Their differences over time are becoming more defined the old girls class is shining through. Let's not forget one bored quieter day on my own last year, I did the Smiler 17 times, 14 straight after each other, so it's not like I don't like it - I do. People know by now the kind of almost juxtaposed position I have on it, in that if they removed it, I wouldn't care if the built it properly or something similar of an Alton Towers standard. I do love it though, and the idea of the theme, the logo, the creativity behind the story is probably my favourite of them all. And, at night, bathed in blue light and fog/smoke it, in the queue, it could almost be an indoor ride as you can barely see the surrounding at all - it gets extremely intimate, it's novel, it's clever, it's challenging in many ways. A bit more care, and it would have been world class and Merlin remain IDIOTS for not seeing this happen.
Had that have happened, maybe, maybe, it would have taken the old girls crown - but, form is temporary, class is permanent. Something will come along and take the Smilers crown soon enough, it's going to age horribly, the theme and music will become unbelievably annoying in a few years when it's all run down - which it will be, because even a season in, it's all creaking, and Broken Effects thread proves where it will go at present rate.
It's a shame, a real shame, but Nemesis has a class, it has true theatre, it doesn't rely on novelty and bombarding your senses into submission, the ride comes close - but not so close you can't have a conversation, you queue amongst scenery, and immersed into the ride, even now after so many years of riding this coaster I still watch the nuances of how she glides around the track, the B&M roar, the smiles on the faces, the terror on those who've never ridden, remarkable after all this time!
Alas, few coasters are built that have this kind of "magic", it sounds like Helix at front at night possibly beats it, but this is that kind of ride, one that comes along every so often.
Wardley was, and remains, a genius. I don't love Nemesis/Oblivion because of Wardley, I love Wardley because of Nemesis/Oblivion.
With the technology nowadays, how I wish he would create a swansong coaster just to see if he can beat his two arguably best creations.
So that is why, for me, after a good season or so of both together, I have a fondness for The Smiler, but it just doesn't beat the enduring experience, theatre, and class of the ubiquitous Nemesis.