I think The Smiler is amazing in many ways. Sure it's rough as Gerst coasters always are, the quality of the build was compromised by an appalling winter, its somewhat repetitive, and the theme seems a great idea done on a budget, but...
...it makes amazing use of the space available, it won Towers a headline grabbing world record despite stifling planning limitations, its incredibly imposing as you queu under it, and it really does what it says on the tin. I always come off it grinning like a Cheshire cat even thought I don't know why. It can't stand up to Nemesis, but then what can.
I groaned at the idea of sticking VR onto Air, it seemed pointless, but the graphics look great, the space theme may stand out like a sore thumb from off the ride, but could be immerse ON the ride and it seems to have the backing of JW. It's starting to win me over, but I won't know for sure until I ride it.