I went on it this Monday, and there's lots of space for improvement, and not only physical mind you personally. I'd definitely start with the Hide N Seek and flying heads. The stuff from Duel are still present in there, just replace the zombies and add new and better lighting, for the heads, from my recent rides, the new heads are way too slow, and I think it's because of the weight of the new heads as they're much bigger than the older ones. Either make smaller head props or bring the old ones back (if possible) and dl them up for the new theme. Sound effects would hugely improve that scene with screams coming from the heads like the old ones.
A change I do think is worth looking into is making it a bit more family friendly. Altons Towers was packed when I visited, but Alton Manors queue was dead, and a good chunk of the people riding it were young teens and adults, sometimes the queue would be empty for nearly 10 minutes with no one entering it. For a family attraction for everyone to enjoy, I think they failed pretty badly personally, so just make it a little more family friendly during the closed season for wider appeal, OR why not have it open during the closed season for Christmas events and do it up with a more family friendly theme every year, it could work. I hang around Gloomy Woods for quite a bit mind you when I visit, and I've seen quite a few kids just outright refusing to ride it again after their first go on it.
As for it being overhyped, I do agree to a certain extent. I've seen many Enthusiast vloggers calling it Europe's Best Dark ride, which I don't agree with sorry.
I agree what the 2 scenes you mentioned, but I don’t agree with it being toned down. It’s already fairly tame from its original “HH” most ghost trains/haunted manor are far scarier for kids.
Let’s be honest It has a ridiculously high throughput, it’s the only ride in that area. With quite a walk ill add, I don’t think that judgment reflects it’s popularity!
I also agree if we get rid of “nostalgia that blinds many clear judgment” The original haunted house would not be sufficient. I mean it didn’t even have a story really?
The designers did a fantastic job incorporating the bits enthusiasts admire with the new, whilst keeping some of the old feel (you can’t please everyone)
Most of wanted the guns removed
Mechanics reused and refurbished
New effects added
A ride that’s not dominated by screens
A good story with the themed music throughout
A good take on the old fashioned haunted house/ghost train
Non ip based rude
Care and passion (countless Easter eggs)
The ride was made for the general public of course but they clearly put so much time and thought to please us enthusiasts. I honestly feel sometimes if they ever read their forums, the poor designers will be so deflated. Probably feel next time why bother? They didn’t need to, but they did actually accommodate to all of our needs vastly! You only have to look at the countless Easter eggs and what they tried to keep or bring back.
Not everyone will be happy with every part, of course not. But surely we can all appreciate the passion and effort that’s gone into the ride, to please us fans on such a budget. That alone wins my vote and I guarantee when they shut it down in 15 years time for a IP overall, we’re all be moaning with nostalgia that we want it back!