Time for a review. Please note
this will not be spoiler free, so look away now, all those still to watch tonight's episode.
I thought this episode was stunning. Last week's episode admittedly felt dull but it was great prelude for tonight, showing how normal life intertwines with the adventures of the Doctor. For those who thought this needed two episodes worth of time, I initially agreed however, I think that one episode was good enough to secure a completely action-packed story with lots going on.
My main criticism is that some elements could have been missed out entirely and replaced with superior scenes. The whole Ming vase thing was a little unnecessary and I felt that the character (who's name escapes me) who collected the angel wasn't needed and added little to the story for the time it took to get into his role. I also think that the cherub laughter wasn't menacing enough (sing-song voices are better than just a weak giggle) and when the candle went out (before Rory got sent to the Angel's 'farm') it appeared to have been blown out by the cherub - this idea defeats the principle (and sole basis of their existence) of them being unable to move you are looking at them. Elements of paradoxes were really over-complicated and could have easily been watered down.
Despite those picky points, the episode was great. It had plenty of movement and scenes of edginess. I
adored the use of the Statue of Liberty (specifically those frightening teeth) and the Angel chase sequences were really jumpy. The Angels didn't just look scary tonight, they had an evil air about them, and the idea of them owning a human 'battery farm' was even bordering on sinister.
As for Rory & Amy's demise, it was beautifully executed. If they had both had a dramatic monologue it would've been boring, but the combination of Amy's decision and the quick, unexpected attack on Rory was fantastic. Rory's character, tonight, had more dynamic than ever before and did not feel unnecessary. His demise was so shockingly quick and punchy that the emotional scene with Amy that followed worked really well. As usual River annoyed me, but the scene where she lied about her wrist was fantastic. Matt Smith, for the fifth episode this series, was brilliant in his acting and his character's depth really poured out tonight. The 'Afterword' was a heart-wrenching scene, and despite the tackiness of the sepia freeze-frame at the end, I felt that it tied everything up perfectly.
I have no choice to award it a convincing 9/10, as despite the imperfections, it brought a tear to my eye and was a fitting end to a great series and set of companions.