We all wanted her out? I'm not so sure about that, I certainly didn't. I was very sad when she left, she did a brilliant job overall.
I didn't want her out either.
I agree, many didn't want her out - including me.
She did the resort a lot of good, brought back it's uniqueness and it's identity that was lost between 2004-2007 and just "got" the different departments and their requirements/expertise and left them to deal with it.
Marketing of course must have an influence within every department in order for the brand to succeed. However, at Alton Towers, it is no longer a department that brings everything together and makes the different aspects coherent, it's a department which exercise their "authority" over every single aspect.
I.E. They didn't like some elements of the original "The Wonders Of Sir Algenon's Attic" set; Jack the Knife from Carnival - they were funny about names suggested for him; "Mass Marmilisation/Smiler Themed show" for 2013 fireworks they didn't like; neither did they like the second idea of rides battling each other...
It's things like
this which people are getting at in this discussion. We're not up in arms and saying that marketing are too controlling over "the brand" but are concerned and up in arms about the fact that they control far
too much for the resort to progress healthily and the departments to work to the best of their abilities.
Thorpe Park and Chessington are not so heavily "policed" by marketing like Alton Towers seem to be, of course they have strict brand rules but entertainments etc are allowed more freedom...and they're within the same company!
Take a rather well known safari and adventure park - I was shocked last year when I joined at how little marketing controlled it and my god did they need to control the brand further, helping push old management last year to create a tag-line and become "adventurous" through their image, presentation and language.
This year, they've suddenly lost identity and it is all very mish mash with so many different directions and images seen of one brand...if the new god-awful management change and a shake up various departments happens, then perhaps slowly it may be able to be saved.
However, during their branding and shake up of direction in 2013/early 2014 did they ever stop me producing the scripting/audio/material for various events and rides because they didn't like the script or the names or the characters or the storyline? No, the old management realised entertainments needed to work
creatively with the brand and as long as I was hitting certain points and applying certain "phrases", I was pretty much left to my own devices.
Marketing should indeed ensure the brand is always coherent and reflected throughout the product but they should not be sacrificing creativity/ideas just for the sake of it and because they feel they have the final say.