• ℹ️ Heads up...

    This is a popular topic that is fast moving Guest - before posting, please ensure that you check out the first post in the topic for a quick reminder of guidelines, and importantly a summary of the known facts and information so far. Thanks.

Mitch Hawker coaster polls 2012-13

John

TS Member
Favourite Ride
Steel Vengeance
It’s that time of the year again – the Mitch Hawker coaster poll is back. The wooden ballot is now online at http://www.ushsho.com/bestrollercoasterpoll.htm. Unlike other polls, the MH poll attempts to eliminate bias towards coasters at popular parks by comparing the relative positions of rides on each ballot, rather than how many times a ride appears towards the top (which favours rides more people have been on).

If you’re new to this poll, the full instructions can be found in the spoiler box below, alternatively our very own Jordan has developed a simple ballot helper to take you through the process, which can be found here.

1. Starting with the template linked above, add your email, name and location on the lines indicated.
2. rank the 6 “ride experiences”, 1 being the best
3. delete every ride you have never ridden.
4. replace the first ‘n’ with a ‘y’ for each coaster you have ridden
5. replace the 2nd ‘n’ with a ‘y’ if you rode that coaster in 2012
6. replace the 0 with your numerical ranking of each ride. (0 is considered worse than any other number). You may give two or more rides the same ranking if you wish.
7. E-mail your completed ballot to [email protected] with 2012 Wood Poll as the subject


Do not change any of the lines other than in the ways listed above – in particular do not replace “fav steel” with the name of your favourite steel coaster, the vote counting program will ignore any lines it does not recognise.

Ballots will be accepted until 8th Jan 2013

For the 3rd year running I’ll be using ballots posted in this thread to produce a TowersStreet mini-poll to see how the opinions of people on this forum compares to those of the wider enthusiast community. Last year there were 17 ballots posted, hopefully we can get a few more this time!

NOTE: At the moment there's a problem with the ballot text file and half of it is missing, hopefully it'll be fixed soon. In the meantime, Jordan's site includes all the coasters on the ballot. Anyone updating a previous ballot can use the list of changes in the instructions file and the 2011 ballot. Use these at your own risk - any line on your ballot not recognised by the ballot tabulation program will be ignored!
 
Well now that I have a few more wooden coasters to add to the list this'll be a bit more interesting. Such a shame the steel coaster poll seems to have died :(

Will post my ballot soon.
 
Jordan said:
I think the steel poll will be returning in the new year :)
I know that the wooden poll always comes before the steel poll but there have now been two wooden polls since the last steel one as there was no steel poll for 2011.
 
I've been in contact with Mitch and he intends to run the steel poll again. The steel poll is much more difficult to organise as there are far more steel coasters operating worldwide, which makes updating the ballot a significant task.

Anyway, to kick things off, here's the business end of my ballot (I'm using [/tt] tags for readability):

[tt]My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR,y,y,2
Colossos Heide Park DE,y,n,3
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,4
Megafobia Oakwood UK,y,n,5
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,6
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,7
Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL,y,y,8
Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL,y,y,8
The Bandit Movie Park DE,y,y,9
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,10
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,11
Antelope Gulliver's World UK,y,n,12
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,y,13[/tt]
 
Well, I guess I should post mine too, seeing as I am a bit of a woodie fan! And finally after so long my wooden poll ballot is worth posting as it now has more than just the Blackpool Woodies! :p

My list is as follows;

[tt]My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR,y,y,2
Troy Toverland NL,y,y,3
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,4
Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL,y,y,5
Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL,y,y,6
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,7
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,8
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,9
The Bandit Movie Park DE,y,y,10
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,11[/tt]
 
My entry :)

[tt]My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR,y,y,2
Troy Toverland NL,y,n,3
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,4
Colossos Heide Park DE,y,n,5
Megafobia Oakwood UK,y,n,6
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,7
Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL,y,n,8
Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL,y,n,9
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,10
Robin Hood Walibi Holland NL,y,n,11
Loup Garou Walibi Belgium BE,y,n,12
Coaster-Express Parque Warner Madrid ES,y,y,13
The Bandit Movie Park DE,y,n,14
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,15
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,16
Anaconda Walygator Parc FR,y,n,17
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,y,18[/tt]
 
Thanks for asking John.

I've got my Ballot:



[tt]My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Balder Liseberg SE,y,n,2
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,3
Mammut Tripsdrill DE,y,y,4
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,n,5
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,n,6
Roller Coaster Great Yarmouth UK,y,n,7
Tomahawk Port Aventura ES,y,n,8
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,n,9
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,n,10
Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK,y,n,11[/tt]



I hope that this year two of my major coasters (Balder and Mammut) actually get counted. Unlikely though as I can only think of 1 or 2 other that have been on them.
 
[tt]Balder Liseberg SE,y,n,1
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,n,2
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,3
Stampida Port Aventura ES,y,y,4
Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR,y,n,5
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,6
Magnus Colossus Terra Mitica ES,y,n,7[/tt]

I feel I have some explaining to do with TDZ. I think I must have caught it on a serious off day or something because it just seemed incredibly rough and I didn't get any of the airtime or extreme laterals that people rave about.

This year, I rode Stampida. It too was incredibly rough, probably even more so but it had the forces that TDZ seemed to be lacking on my visit. If TDZ normally offers a ride like that, I can see it being a much better coaster but the Mitch Hawker Poll is no place for such speculation and for now, I can only judge it on the rides it gave on the day.

I think I need to go back to Parc Asterix and give TDZ another chance. It's an excuse to ride OzIris too!

Edit- I completely forgot that Wild Mouse is a wooden coaster, damn! Ah well, it's sent now. It'll have to wait till next year.
 
[tt]COASTER NAME PARK LOC <--Please leave this
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,2
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,3
Gwazi-Tiger Busch Gardens-Tampa FL,y,n,4
Gwazi-Lion Busch Gardens-Tampa FL,y,n,5
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,6
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,7
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,8
Antelope Gulliver's World UK,y,n,9
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,y,10[/tt]

I used to love the Nash, but I had a really awful few rides on it earlier in the season and its made me really fall out of love with it.
 
Still undecided as to whether Blue Fire is better than Wild Mouse, but nonetheless.. :)

[tt]COASTER NAME PARK LOC
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,1
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,2
Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK,y,n,3
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,4
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,5
Roller Coaster Great Yarmouth UK,y,n,6
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,7
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,8
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,y,9[/tt]
 
[tt]COASTER NAME PARK LOC <--Please leave this
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Megafobia Oakwood UK,y,n,2
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,3
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,4
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,5
Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL,y,y,6
Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL,y,y,7
GhostRider Knott's Berry Farm CA,y,n,8
Apocalypse S. F. Magic Mountain CA,y,n,9
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,10
Scenic Railway (S) Dreamland UK,y,n,11
Colossus S.F. Magic Mountain CA,y,n,12
Giant Dipper Santa Cruz Bch Bdwk CA,y,n,13
The Bandit Movie Park DE,y,y,14
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,15
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,y,16[/tt]

What do you all think of my choices? :)

I find it oddly satisfying that the Big Dipper beats the Giant Dipper in my rankings.
 
Nothing too controversial, though I thought you might have put Bandit a bit higher after our mini marathon session on it.

Thanks to everyone who's taken part so far ;D

CGM said:
Edit- I completely forgot that Wild Mouse is a wooden coaster, damn! Ah well, it's sent now. It'll have to wait till next year.
You may not be able to change your official ballot, but you can always change your TST ballot ;)

Tim said:
I hope that this year two of my major coasters (Balder and Mammut) actually get counted. Unlikely though as I can only think of 1 or 2 other that have been on them.
Balder is already in, I only require 2 riders for a coaster to be included - otherwise there'd only be about 8 rides on the list. Not sure about Mammut, feel free to nag people into participating though!
 
[tt]COASTER NAME PARK LOC <--Please leave this
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR,y,y,2
Troy Toverland NL,y,n,3
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,4
Colossos Heide Park DE,y,n,5
Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL,y,y,6
Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL,y,y,7
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,n,8
Megafobia Oakwood UK,y,n,9
Robin Hood Walibi Holland NL,y,n,10
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,n,11
Gwazi-Lion Busch Gardens-Tampa FL,y,n,12
Gwazi-Tiger Busch Gardens-Tampa FL,y,n,13
Loup Garou Walibi Belgium BE,y,n,14
Tomahawk Port Aventura ES,y,n,15
Coaster-Express Parque Warner Madrid ES,y,y,16
The Bandit Movie Park DE,y,n,17
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,n,18
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,n,19
Stampida Port Aventura ES,y,n,20
Anaconda Walygator Parc FR,y,n,21
Antelope Gulliver's World UK,y,n,22
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,n,23[/tt]

Tonnerre de Zeus is victorious - it really returned to form in 2012!

:D
 
Here's mine:

[tt]My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,n,1
Stampida Port Aventura ES,y,n,2
Gwazi-Tiger Busch Gardens-Tampa FL,y,y,3
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,n,4
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,n,5
Tomahawk Port Aventura ES,y,n,6[/tt]

Regarding Gwazi, when I went earlier this year for the first time, only one side was running so that was all I was able to experience unfortunately.
 
[tt]RANK THE FOLLOWING RIDING SENSATIONS <-LEAVE THIS LINE AS IS
Abrupt Airtime_____________________________,y,y,0
Floating Airtime___________________________,y,y,0
Lateral Forces_____________________________,y,y,0
Out of Control Feeling/Directional Changes_,y,y,0
Positive G's/Loops_________________________,y,y,0
Sensation of Speed_________________________,y,y,0
COASTER NAME PARK LOC <--Please leave this
My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere **,y,y,1
Wild Mouse Blackpool UK,y,y,2
Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK,y,y,3
Roller Coaster Great Yarmouth UK,y,n,4
Big Dipper Blackpool UK,y,y,5
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,6
Blue Flyer Blackpool UK,y,n,7
Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK,y,n,8[/tt]

Only done BPBPBPB and Yarmouth's woodies so far, but every little helps I guess! I've put the extra forces bit as well, I thought it would be nice to see what floats other peoples boat in that respect also. :)
 
I think their might be an issue with the sensations section of Jordan's helper. Should it say 0 after all the sensations? It did that to me to but I just assumed it was an error on my part.
 
John said:
Nothing too controversial, though I thought you might have put Bandit a bit higher after our mini marathon session on it.

Haha, I did enjoy it, but I realised that was more in a 'so bad it's good way'. I think placing it any higher would be slight fanboyism. Though in retrospect, maybe I should have placed it higher than Giant Dipper.

Adam James said:
Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK,y,n,3
Grand National Blackpool UK,y,y,4
Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE,y,y,5

Oh come off it, seriously? :p
 
Tim said:
I think their might be an issue with the sensations section of Jordan's helper. Should it say 0 after all the sensations? It did that to me to but I just assumed it was an error on my part.

Apologies, should be fixed now :)
 
Top