This made me laugh!
TT getting grief is laughable ;D - ok they get a bit of a ribbing from time to time, it's usually done quite tongue in cheek - and I'm a newbie with zero bias to either site what so ever.
Cor deary me, my mates give me more stick than TT have gotten on here lol! Seriously.
What's more, it was a valid point, and one ripe for discussion - but I can tell you one thing, reading through this forum, the members spend enough time giving the staff here stick about what they're doing, never mind commenting about others of any kind!
Yes, me included!!
You took a section of your public forum, that's meant to attract visitors, then made it private. I respect your decision, it's your site - but if you were to ask me what the point was, there is only one, to try and use a more strong arm method to attract more memberships - I've been around the net a long, long time. Either that, or well, it doesn't actually have a point and is, shall we say, counter intuitive?
The guys here try to keep a more open forum, and are open to being given some stick about it too.
I don't agree with everyone here, or everything this forum does, and I say when I don't. However in this case, I think I have to stand up for this rubbish about TT being got at constantly on here. It's just not true at all!
Sorry to tell you Adz, you seem like a nice guy and I genuinely mean no disrespect whatsoever, but seriously, forums are not that important to most of us, that we consistently need to discuss the actions of other ones we don't even necessarily frequent. One or two members may discuss it, especially previous ones - but there are a great multitude of us who to be frank, couldn't give monkeys uncle.
As good a forum as it is here, it is still, just a forum, as is yours.
I wish you good luck with it, but with so much effort being put into here, and so many new members with zero knowledge or care of this issue, I had to stand up and defend that point.
Anyway I hope you don't take it personally, but I speak on behalf of the many of us here who put much effort and time into our posts, in an attempt to engage and discuss/debate with others the many varied and fascinating attributes of the enthusiast world.