Any one of the big 3 woodies would be an ideal choice for me.
Grand National: Opened in 1935, BPB''s most intense coaster and my personal favourite. It's one of only a handful of continuous track coasters in the world and all things historical aside, it's a bloody good ride. Featuring two double drops, and great airtime this is a legendary ride.
Nickelodeon Streak: Opened in 1933, and spending most of its life operating under the name RollerCoaster until Nickelodeon Land opened in 2011, this classic out and back woodie has to be one of the smoothest wooden coasters in the world. This classic ride uses the lift hill from the defunct Velvet Coaster which closed in the early 30''s and was up until 2006 still running without any form of seat belts or restraints. The ride was rerouted at some point taking the final bend round the back of the first drop.
Big Dipper: Opened in 1923, rerouted 1936. This was the first coaster to use under track friction wheels which allowed for steeper drops than anything before it. This classic ride used to actually stand on the beach before the promenade drove the sea back. The ride was extended after the two new coasters made the original ride look somewhat tame.
Of course there is the Big One, but personally speaking that's a very over rated ride that has reasonably impressive states. If you want a truly great, historic and nostalgic coaster, you have three classics to pick from.