Rupert said:
A rollercoaster themed to a sinister, dystopian, Orwellian organisation with a currently unknown motive could surely rank amongst the most genius coaster themes of all time. It would also give a plausible and intriguing back story to X Sector.
Genius? Really? I mean as rollercoaster themes go it'd be a slight change but if SW7 were to follow this theme, it would be an idea lifted directly from 1984. That's not genius, that's using someone else's idea.
In fact I don't even think it would be particularly original, I would argue that what you just described has already been done with Oblivion.
I don't know, something about this supposed Orwellian theme doesn't sit right with me. I've always liked Alton's unusually dark themes for their coasters in the form of Nemesis and Oblivion. But recently, I feel that Merlin is beginning to push it with the sheer number of new rides across its parks with a bleak theme.
At Alton, the problem isn't necessarily with SW7, it's what came before it. What should have been family friendly rides with themes to fit have been given theming and marketing usually reserved for major thrill attractions.
Since Thirteen and the Dark Forest re-theme, I think that Alton has lost the balance of lighthearted attractions vs. darker ones that previously made the park so enticing and magical. Now it seems that every new attraction is trying to be more apocalyptic and doom-tastic that the last.
I feel that Alton is at risk of turning into Thorpe. Soon every area will be terrorised by some sort of alien, a natural disaster, sinister government organisation or malevolent plant life. For me, in a good theme park most of the rides and areas should have a family friendly atmosphere with a few areas further afield that feel much more dark and dangerous. This maintains a sense of adventure. Get it wrong and you end up with Misery World.
SW7 being in X-Sector, it pretty much has to have a bleak theme. I just wish Alton had planned Thirteen and N:ST around this. They don't seem to be good at considering how new rides will affect the atmosphere of the park as an overall attraction.