Smilertron
TS Member
Maybe in some cases, because the vast majority of enthusiasts have ridden most of the rides available to them, the excitement comes from different experiences rather than the ride hardware itself. Meaning, you could take very average ride hardware and highly theme it to add a new experience ala Disney, Universal etc. Sorry if this is stating obvious but maybe this is what enthusiasts need to get the same kicks, hence why Wickerman has been recieved slightly warmer than ICON, due to the general experience. The one thing i have heard people talk about a lot on ICON is the mist effects in the tunnel, which adds to the 'experience'. Apologies if this doesn't make sense, i was having a bit of a brain dump haha. Maybe several interactions with other rides, isn't quite as exciting as say smoke, fire, water and general theming. I love ICON though.