Tinkering the music isn't exactly low cost when it needs to be produced from scratch, no matter which geek blowing smoke up their own arse they use.
I think you're overestimating the cost of music. Tbh, I think everyone does.
Even the likes of IMA Score are cheap for short tracks (like the entrance they've done for Park VIBES). Over the last couple of years, they've got people within the community to produce music too, which is probably even cheaper.
At the very least, the cost of any new music they've got is so minimal that any money they've put into it wouldn't put a dent in any project across the park that needs doing.
There was nothing wrong with the original Swarm audio, it was one of the few things that didn't need messing with.
It's funny, in the past lots of people complained that the Swarm audio was weak / bland / boring / not-memorable / generally pretty meh. Since the change happened I haven't seen such comments. Whether those people have just had a change of heart, egg on their face or what, I don't know. Not saying that's you or anyone here in particular, just a fun observation I've noticed.
For me, I always felt Swarm's audio was the weakest part of the area, but it was fine. Anyone who visited Fright Nights last year might have noticed Swarm Invasion got a new soundtrack, also done by Nick Hutson. It was a bit creepier, a bit more dramatic, and featured the YM@S song too. I quite liked that. It worked very nicely. I would have been quite happy if it was used full time.
The current Swarm audio is weird. It plays out like a radio station. Such an idea can work (see WWTP), but it doesn't here. A couple of reasons for that:
1. The radio voiceovers are so bland. They sound bored. There's no panic when talking about alien abductions or anything. There's no irony either.
2. It shoehorns everything in. YM@S have a song called 'The Swarm'. The audio explains it's a conspiracy theory by the band. That billboard with adverts on? The adverts are in the radio clips. The near 10 year old video clips used to advertise the ride? They're referenced. It's heavy handed ways of trying to appeal to enthusiasts, and it feels forced, clunky and awkward.
3. It's got songs that reference destruction and such; eg: Zombie. But it doesn't work like WWTP does, as it's not era appropriate and not cleverly blended it.
There's also some of the Fright Nights loop blended in too.
Swarm's audio was fine in my books. Using the Swarm Invasion loop would have been a suitable evolution which would have been nice. The current set up is heavy handed, clunky and simply not for me.
As I understand it the area around Detonator and the 4D cinema previously had a pirates’ theme. When they planned Tidal Wave they originally looked at a pirate theme, but Legoland already had a pirate theme log flume, and they thought that the Amity Cove theme would be more interesting (which I think it was). Then they replaced Pirates 4D with the Time Voyagers film, and any sense of a theme that the area previously had was lost.
Pirated 4D came about in 1999, and the idea was to develop a pirate themed area, yes. The film wasn't made for the park (I believe it was at some SeaWorld parks before Thorpe, but Thorpe was the first non-American park to get it).
Early plans for Tidal Wave were to have it as pirate themed, featuring particularly a large pirate ship theming feature the size of the ride. I'm not quite sure why plans for the pirate area were dropped (it could be because nearby Legoland and Chessington had pirate areas themselves, or they simply wanted the Americana style, or a different reason). But when Detonator came about in 2001, it didn't really have a theme since it was only meant to be temporary. It was loosely put in with the pirate theme (having canons dotted around) to make the best of it.
Really that whole mini section of the park never fit in at any point.
If I’m being honest, I’m still not really sure on this new audio, personally. I quite liked the atmosphere that the old audio created.
Although I guess it’s not really my place to complain; I should really be more grateful…
If you don't like changes, you don't like them. It's not a question of whether you should be grateful or not. Ultimately, you're, in one sense or another, a paying customer who visits the park because you want an enjoyable day out. If you don't like something, that's absolutely fine tbh, so long as you have a reason beyond 'I hate it because I do'.
Obviously it's better to keep a more open mind until you experience things in person. But even then, you'll know the sort of thing you like and don't like beforehand anyway.
If people don't share their fair and honest opinions in a constructive way, and think they should be grateful for any change, then parks will just do changes for the sake of change (or, worse, cost cutting), and away with it.
---
I visited the park today (the TPM posts are mine!). Really, the event is not my cup of tea. The whole thing creates a festival, but bordering on fairground, vibe across the park, which isn't my thing. The music overlays for the event are cringey and of a particular taste.
It is nice to see more entertainment across the park. Dancers, singers, etc. It's nice little things to break up the day, mix things up, etc. They're not shows or set times; if you see them when they're performing, you can either walk on by, or stop for a bit and enjoy. It's stuff like that which can work at a park like Thorpe. The presentation is the big issue.
I also think it shouldn't be understated that Thorpe are doing events again. And in fairness, they've managed to create an event which is spread evenly across the park and is consistent across the board.
Obviously the reaction on here is more on the negative side. And my reaction is shared. It's quite clear whatever audience they're targeting with this event, a lot of people on forums like this aren't in it. In theory, that's fine as we make up such a small percentage of the overall visitor numbers, and you can't always cater for everyone. The bigger question is: will the audience who are being targeted visit? And will they enjoy it? At the moment, I don't know.